Popular on eTradeWire
- Phoenix Home Remodeling Co-owner Releases Practical Remodel Guide That Helps Homeowners - 378
- New Medium Article Explores Why Emotional Conversations Fail and What Most People Don't Understand About Connection - 143
- SmartReply® Secures Trademark as Platform Becomes Leading Solution for Social Media Comment Moderation and Customer Service - 139
- Does EMDR Really Work? New Article Explores How Trauma Gets Stuck in the Brain and How Healing Begins - 136
- Edison Lloyd Thomas Reaches #1 Bestseller Status After Encouragement From Bestselling Author Raun Shephard - 122
- QEEA AI Announces Official Platform Launch, Redefining How People Interact With A.I - 117
- Iverson Jordan Smith Emerges as a Rising Senior Basketball Prospect - 116
- $80 Million Revenue Backlog for AI Cybersecurity Company Building the Future of Integrated Cybersecurity and Public Safety: $CYCU - 115
- Ultimate Business Capital Launches Institutional Services for Receivables Buyers - 114
- CONTACT of Ocean & Monmouth Counties Reflects on a Year of Impact - 113
Similar on eTradeWire
- Kaufman & Kaufman, LLC Provides Guidance for Workers Injured in Winter Slip-and-Fall Accidents
- Jones Law Firm Launches Westminster Divorce Attorneys Page to Serve Families Seeking Clear, Strategic Guidance
- How a Legislative Typo Created a Temporary Tax Haven for Nordic Casino Operators in 2026
- Jones Law Firm, PC Launches Littleton Divorce & Family Law Attorneys Page
- New York Based Law Firm Recognizes Parth Singh as a Rising Force in International Law
- Probate Shepherd® Announces a New Member Probate Attorney in Arlington, TX
- Probate Shepherd® Announces a New Member Probate Attorney in Conroe, TX
- Probate Shepherd® Announces a New Member Probate Attorney in Fort Worth, TX
- Jacob Emrani's Annual "Supper Bowl" Expected To Donate Thousands Of Meals
- Kahana Feld Continues National Growth Strategy with the Addition of Five New Partners
Some in Media Misunderstand Law Regarding Garcia
eTradeWire News/10801691
Don't Know the Difference Between Deportation and Withholding Orders
WASHINGTON - eTradeWire -- - Many reporters who cover the White House flunked a recent test to see if they knew even the basics of the law related to the situation of Abrego Garcia. They all flunked!
Asked what would happen if Garcia was brought back to the U.S., many thought he would be returned to his family. That's incorrect!
Asked if they knew the difference between a deportation order and withholding order, not a single participating reporter was able to answer correctly.
The legally correct answer, says Banzhaf, is that an order of deportation had already been issued years ago after a legal proceeding during which Garcia received due process. So, even if he were somehow brought back to the U.S., he would be deported; he would not be allowed to return to his family and his studies.
Those supporters who do have a better understanding of the law are insisting that Garcia be returned to the U.S. so that his WOR can be revoked by an administrative judge at a hearing.
More on eTradeWire News
But virtually all commentators seem to assume that such an 8 C.F.R. § 208.24(f) hearing before an immigration judge can only be held in the U.S.
But this is also incorrect, notes Banzhaf, because it fails to consider a simple and frequently used alternative: a video teleconference hearing over the Internet [Internet-Based Hearing] while Garcia is still in El Salvador,
Indeed, the court's written decision validates as legally permissible an analysis (https://www.washingtonexaminer.com/news/washington-secrets/3380527/returning-kilmar-abrego-garcia-el-salvador-exercise-in-futility-legal-scholars/) Banzhaf published much earlier which could keep Garcia in El Salvador while still providing him with the due process which the law requires.
Such a hearing could be held via video teleconference (Internet-Based Hearing or Hearing by Video Conference) with Garcia (and perhaps his lawyer) in El Salvador, and the other participants in the U.S.
More on eTradeWire News
The use of such Internet-based hearings by immigration authorities is very frequent and well established
Since the hearing would be held before an immigration judge who is an employee of the Department of Justice, and his boss (the Attorney General) has argued very strongly against returning Garcia to the U.S., the immigration judge is quite likely to terminate Garcia's WOR status.
In short, a single hearing over the Internet from El Salvador could both revoke Garcia's WOR protection against being sent to El Salvador, and also reaffirm his order of removal from the U.S., says Banzhaf, although whether that's the way the Trump administration wishes to proceed is far from clear.
http://banzhaf.net/ jbanzhaf3ATgmail.com @profbanzhaf
Asked what would happen if Garcia was brought back to the U.S., many thought he would be returned to his family. That's incorrect!
Asked if they knew the difference between a deportation order and withholding order, not a single participating reporter was able to answer correctly.
The legally correct answer, says Banzhaf, is that an order of deportation had already been issued years ago after a legal proceeding during which Garcia received due process. So, even if he were somehow brought back to the U.S., he would be deported; he would not be allowed to return to his family and his studies.
Those supporters who do have a better understanding of the law are insisting that Garcia be returned to the U.S. so that his WOR can be revoked by an administrative judge at a hearing.
More on eTradeWire News
- Investing in Property Through a Self-Managed Super Fund (SMSF)
- Christina Aldan Newest Anatomy & Physiology Instructor
- The World's No.1 Superstar® Brings Disco Fever Back With New Global Single and Video "Disco Dancing"
- Church of Scientology Airs Messages of Purpose in Winter Olympics Coverage
- Helix Group Enterprises. Built properly. Built to last
But virtually all commentators seem to assume that such an 8 C.F.R. § 208.24(f) hearing before an immigration judge can only be held in the U.S.
But this is also incorrect, notes Banzhaf, because it fails to consider a simple and frequently used alternative: a video teleconference hearing over the Internet [Internet-Based Hearing] while Garcia is still in El Salvador,
Indeed, the court's written decision validates as legally permissible an analysis (https://www.washingtonexaminer.com/news/washington-secrets/3380527/returning-kilmar-abrego-garcia-el-salvador-exercise-in-futility-legal-scholars/) Banzhaf published much earlier which could keep Garcia in El Salvador while still providing him with the due process which the law requires.
Such a hearing could be held via video teleconference (Internet-Based Hearing or Hearing by Video Conference) with Garcia (and perhaps his lawyer) in El Salvador, and the other participants in the U.S.
More on eTradeWire News
- Branded by Marivel™ Launches as a Handmade Jewelry Brand Rooted in Intentional Design
- Aversa Outdoor Expands Professional Landscaping and Outdoor Living Services in Bradenton, FL
- Free AI For Business Summit Reveals 2026 Growth Blueprint for Small Businesses
- Charlotte County Employers Confront Workforce Retention Challenges Driven by Housing Availablity
- GB Specialist Access Solutions Delivers Technical Façade Inspection at Golden Square
The use of such Internet-based hearings by immigration authorities is very frequent and well established
Since the hearing would be held before an immigration judge who is an employee of the Department of Justice, and his boss (the Attorney General) has argued very strongly against returning Garcia to the U.S., the immigration judge is quite likely to terminate Garcia's WOR status.
In short, a single hearing over the Internet from El Salvador could both revoke Garcia's WOR protection against being sent to El Salvador, and also reaffirm his order of removal from the U.S., says Banzhaf, although whether that's the way the Trump administration wishes to proceed is far from clear.
http://banzhaf.net/ jbanzhaf3ATgmail.com @profbanzhaf
Source: Public Interest Law Professor John Banzhaf
Filed Under: Legal
0 Comments
Latest on eTradeWire News
- Market Rebound and Sector Rotation Highlighted in New Insights from Steven Sitkowski
- The Standard Salon renovates it's Roseville location, announces 2026 apprenticeships and extensions
- Northwest Modern Fabrication Expands Manufacturing Capacity With 4,800 Sq. Ft. Addition
- Patrick Finney Lists From-the-Studs Denver Redevelopment Opportunity Near Empower Field
- People & Stories/Gente y Cuentos to Host Award-Winning Novelist Susan Choi for Spring Literary Benefit Event
- Lee County Legal Aid Society to host next free clinic for area seniors
- My Grief Angels Releases Valentine's Day Video Supporting Grievers Returning to Work
- NRE-HEALTH Radio Launches With a New Approach to Health Broadcasting
- Andrew-Thomas Contractors Enhances Aurora Fence Service Page
- Barcelona Flamenco Ballet and Rodney Marsalis Philadelphia Big Brass to Perform in Fort Myers
- THINKWARE Announces Valentine's Day Promotional Pricing Across ARC and U3000 Dash Cam Lineup
- BOHO Design Rentals Expands Luxury Dining Table Rental Collection Across Colorado and California
- Moorpark College Foundation Welcomes New Board Members in 2025/2026
- L-Tron Announces OSCR360 Software Update v.2026.202.0
- Cancer Alliance Network's popular outdoor yoga fundraiser returns to Fort Myers on Feb. 28
- Fulfilling a promise: A.N.A.'s Friends grants 100% of requests in 2025
- Top AGCO Dealers Farm Depot, Caouette & Sons Implements & Tilleman Equipment Partner with Vi
- Better Together honors Northeast Florida community partners at 2026 Doing Good Together reception
- D&L Garage Doors Reinforces Transparent, Local Garage Door Service Across Oregon, Washington & Idaho
- Boulder SEO Marketing Propels Streaming Software Pioneer to 250% Download Surge