Popular on eTradeWire
- San Jose Holiday Lights Returns to Downtown San Jose for the 2026 Season - 1665
- San Jose Holiday Lights: Group Ticket Discounts for Companies, Schools, Organizations - 1620
- The Mako Girls Announce The "MAKO TAKEOVER CONCERT" Live at Center Stage Vinyl In Atlanta - 1083
- Eight Teams Set to Compete in the 2026 MDF Hoop House Tip-Off Classic at Tarrant High School - 561
- Apple Valley Home Sales Fall 10.6% as Active Listings Decline 22.2% in September 2026 - 412
- KeepRobots: 11 Weeks Into FCC Robot Rule, Only 3 Foreign-Made Robot Lines Have Conditional Approval - 371
- Free Admission for Veterans at National Museum of Transportation on Veterans Day - 370
- Silver Wings Arts Program reopens in downtown Louisville with fall/winter workshop schedule - 359
- Talented Learning Unveils 2026 LMS Award Winners - 333
- Bay Street Yard announces Oktoberfest celebration Oct. 17 - 326
Similar on eTradeWire
- ACC St. Louis & MO Veterans Commission Offer Free Legal Estate Planning Clinic
- Unique Visa Services Ltd Expands UK Skilled Worker Visa & Sponsor Licence Advisory Services
- Goldstein, Buckley law firm marks 20 years of collecting Toys for Tots donations
- Supreme Court Tosses Bizarre Trans Ruling
- Feldman Shepherd Named as 2027 'Best Law Firm' by Best Lawyers -- Tier 1 National & Philadelphia
- Immigration enforcement weighs on Florida voters in Nov. 3 midterm elections
- Nykitenko Legal Unveils Institutional Regulatory Defense Framework for Cross-Border Energy Investors Amid Delayed EU-CEE Market Coupling
- New Series of AI Books for Lawyers Launches: ChatGPT, Gemini, Google AI Overviews & Grok
- Brian G. Miller Co., LLC Receives Tier 1 Ranking in the 2027 Edition of Best Law Firms®
- The Villari Firm, PLLC Named to the 2027 Edition of Best Law Firms
A Legal Right to View Executions, or to Delay Them?
eTradeWire News/10849827
Planned Firing Squad Live Streaming Could Raise Constitutional Issues
WASHINGTON - eTradeWire -- The Pentagon's proposal to livestream an execution by firing squad may raise interesting constitutional issues, suggests public interest law professor John Banzhaf, who has written extensively on how some execution-related issues can easily be avoided.
Although courts have repeatedly rejected claims by media outlets that they have a legal right to broadcast executions, the cases involved situations in which the entity carrying out the execution did not wish to permit the process to be broadcast.
But when the entity conducting the execution is willing if not eager to have it broadcast, the legal posture is very different since presenting these images to the public could be considered form of "speech" subject to the First Amendment
This is especially true with regard to the execution of Nidal Hasan because it is being streamed to send a message.
More on eTradeWire News
Defense Secretary Pete Hegseth says he would authorize the livestreaming to send a strong message: "because people need to understand that there's serious consequences for these types of things."
President Donald Trump also said that an argument for showing it is to send a message of deterrence: "By showing it, maybe other people won't be doing what he did."
When events are broadcast to, at least in part, send a message and change public opinion - whether that's MMA fights at the White House or a patriotic parade - they arguably are subject to the First Amendment.
So having chosen to permit the livestreaming of one federal execution to send messages favored by the executive branch, it may be difficult to legally justify refusing to do the same with other federal executions which might send messages opposed by the president, suggests Banzhaf, who notes that similar issues are raised when the president seeks to bar from the White House reporters whom he believes might send messages (make reports) which he opposes.
More on eTradeWire News
Even assuming that using a firing squad to execute murders doesn't by itself constitute "cruel and unusual punishment," livestreaming it to the public might; and raising such an argument could very significantly delay the scheduled execution, argues Banzhaf.
A federal appellate court decision just a few months ago said that forcing a state to permit even a few members of the media to witness an execution risks offending the dignity of the inmate's final moments.
Clearly, livestreaming it to millions, especially since it undoubtedly will be recorded and replayed many times in the future, would much more greatly offend "the dignity of the inmate's final moments," even to the point of possibly infringing on a constitutionally protected interest in privacy, he suggests.
http://banzhaf.net/ jbanzhaf3ATgmail.com @profbanzhaf
Although courts have repeatedly rejected claims by media outlets that they have a legal right to broadcast executions, the cases involved situations in which the entity carrying out the execution did not wish to permit the process to be broadcast.
But when the entity conducting the execution is willing if not eager to have it broadcast, the legal posture is very different since presenting these images to the public could be considered form of "speech" subject to the First Amendment
This is especially true with regard to the execution of Nidal Hasan because it is being streamed to send a message.
More on eTradeWire News
- Emanuel Rose Launches Second Edition of The Agentic Pivot to Help Business Leaders Scale AI Adoption
- Joshua Grasmick Takes World's No. 1 Spot in AI Reasoning and Retrieval, Surpassing NVIDIA, Leading
- Alander Pulliam Torches Modern Victimhood and Youth Shame in Unfiltered Medium Blogs
- Six Nations 2027 Tickets on Sale for All 15 Fixtures, from £225 per Person
- GetBetterBuzz Expands Access to Nicotine-Free Functional Pouches Through Its Online Marketplace
Defense Secretary Pete Hegseth says he would authorize the livestreaming to send a strong message: "because people need to understand that there's serious consequences for these types of things."
President Donald Trump also said that an argument for showing it is to send a message of deterrence: "By showing it, maybe other people won't be doing what he did."
When events are broadcast to, at least in part, send a message and change public opinion - whether that's MMA fights at the White House or a patriotic parade - they arguably are subject to the First Amendment.
So having chosen to permit the livestreaming of one federal execution to send messages favored by the executive branch, it may be difficult to legally justify refusing to do the same with other federal executions which might send messages opposed by the president, suggests Banzhaf, who notes that similar issues are raised when the president seeks to bar from the White House reporters whom he believes might send messages (make reports) which he opposes.
More on eTradeWire News
- Joel Rodriguez Tirado Honors Veterans Day With a Message of Service, Sacrifice, and Legacy
- Beyond the Script Podcast Exposes the Brutal Reality Behind Film & Music Deals with Alander Pulliam
- Leadership in Financial Planning and Client Advocacy
- Tap 42 Craft Kitchen & Bar to host Black Friday Brunch Nov. 27
- Plootus: Retired Couples Face $413,000 Lifetime Healthcare Bill as Medicare Gaps Catch Saver O
Even assuming that using a firing squad to execute murders doesn't by itself constitute "cruel and unusual punishment," livestreaming it to the public might; and raising such an argument could very significantly delay the scheduled execution, argues Banzhaf.
A federal appellate court decision just a few months ago said that forcing a state to permit even a few members of the media to witness an execution risks offending the dignity of the inmate's final moments.
Clearly, livestreaming it to millions, especially since it undoubtedly will be recorded and replayed many times in the future, would much more greatly offend "the dignity of the inmate's final moments," even to the point of possibly infringing on a constitutionally protected interest in privacy, he suggests.
http://banzhaf.net/ jbanzhaf3ATgmail.com @profbanzhaf
Source: Public Interest Law Professor John Banzhaf
Filed Under: Legal
0 Comments
Latest on eTradeWire News
- Dr. Brian Sellers of East Georgia Center for Oral & Facial Surgery Invests in Advanced Training & P
- Zen-Tek's WTR-Tek Offers Safe Solution for Hospital and School Bathroom Renovations
- Wolverine Glass Offers Custom Commercial Glass in Novi and Surrounding Areas
- Commercial Debt Collection Agency Explains Personal Guarantees
- Ann Arbor Chiropractor Gives Ergonomic Office Tips for a Healthy Spine
- Nexodus Clean Honors Veterans and Opens Its Provider Network to Those Ready for Their Next Mission
- Coming Up on Fox Business: Steve Hutchinson Revolutionizes Retirement Planning with Roth Blueprint
- T22 Spartak To Make Its Military-inspired Electric Motorcycle Debut In Dallas
- Love or Lease? Toronto Matchmaker Says Love Is Not a Business Deal
- TCA VG: 2025 Funding Climbs to $9M across 43 Companies; Cumulative Returns Reach 5.3 MOIC & 22% IRR
- Searching for the Next LBE Creator: CalArts Launches First-Ever D.R.E.A.M.S. Pitch Competition
- Patented PACK Portable Assembly Cooler Kit Concept Offers Versatile Solution for Outdoor Convenience and Emergency Preparedness
- As Retirement and Tax Challenges Grow, Phoenix Financial Advisor Chris Kandas Brings a New Generation of Wealth Management to Bloomberg
- CDI Global advises on the sale of Dunbier Marine Products and Mackay Multi Link to 2nd Summit Capital
- Your Pad Thai Just Got a Stock Ticker
- Coming Up on Bloomberg: Chris Kandas Tackles the New Rules of Retirement and Wealth Preservation as Families Face an Uncertain Financial Future
- An AI Plays Kenshi Entirely by Itself, Live 23 Hours a Day, With an AI Host and Chat Voting
- Why Pet Hair Comes Back Two Days After Cleaning
- Study of 2,993 Google Searches Finds Americans Fear Mold Damage Their Homes More Than Health Risks
- Support hands-on agricultural education for children and families at upcoming gala